[R-G] Journalists required to submit to biometric scan in Afghanistan

[Anthony Fenton]

Journalists required to submit to biometric scan in Afghanistan

21 hours ago

OTTAWA — Journalists covering the war in Afghanistan are now required  
to submit to a biometrics scan before being accredited to travel with  
NATO units or visit military bases.

The data, including fingerprints and a retina scan, are used to verify  
identity and apparently checked against an archive of known terrorists.

The new policy, recently posted on the International Security  
Assistance Force website, has not been enforced on Canadian reporters,  
most of whom operate out of Kandahar Airfield.

A legal expert described the new security crackdown as "strange and  
offensive" and said the Conservative government needs to be asking  
tough questions of its allies before any Canadian citizen submits to  
such a procedure.

Michel Drapeau, a retired colonel and expert in access to information,  
said Ottawa should know where the data is being stored, who has access  
to it and how it will be used.

"We are in Afghanistan to defend our values and one of our quasi- 
constitutional values is the right to privacy," Drapeau said Tuesday.

"I would question why they're using that."

Journalists are in Afghanistan to be the eyes and ears of their  
countries and should not be required to figuratively "strip down to  
your bare whatever unless there is a demonstrated need," he said.

Drapeau said he would have fewer concerns if the database was being  
used in an administrative fashion, to catalogue identification in the  
event a journalist is killed. But experience of the last few years  
suggests it will have other uses, he said.

NATO officials in Brussels and Kabul did not respond to requests for  
comment.

A Pentagon publication in the fall of 2007 suggested that the U.S.  
military, which lent the first biometrics equipment to the alliance,  
holds on to the data. It does not guarantee that the information will  
not be shared.

Submitting to the biometrics scan is voluntary, but the accreditation  
instructions noted that "media who do not submit all required  
information will not receive a badge" and that "media interested in  
visiting any ISAF locations (or requesting embed with any ISAF troops)  
in Afghanistan are required to be accredited."

The policy applies to all NATO bases in Afghanistan and goes part of  
the way to explaining why the alliance stopped accrediting journalists  
and issuing them camp passes at Kandahar Airfield in early March.

Reporters were given visitor's passes, which limit their movements and  
make it difficult to leave and return to the base after independently  
interviewing local Afghans. The orange tags also require the Canadian  
Forces to escort journalists at all times - a practice that is  
currently being ignored.

In the first week of March, an Italian photographer embedded with the  
Canadians and at least two other journalists were subject to escorts.  
The Canadian military has loudly protested the policy to the airfield  
commander, with no affect.

The Opposition Liberals and NDP, as well as the Canadian Association  
of Journalists, complained last week that the loss of accreditation  
opened the door to the intimidation of reporters who don't toe the line.

They also considered the visitor's pass system a disincentive to  
independent reporting of the increasingly bloody conflict.

If Canadian reporters want to avoid the restrictions of the visitor's  
pass, they'll have to travel to Kabul and submit to the biometrics  
accreditation.

The high-tech system was initially fielded in Iraq by U.S. forces  
handling prisoners at detention centres, but was quickly expanded and  
used to create identification cards for residents of the embattled  
city of Fallujah.

NATO first began experimenting with the technology in 2007, using  
equipment lent to the International Security Assistance Force by the  
U.S. The idea at the time was to screen local Afghans working at  
military bases.

In fact the Biometrics Automated Toolset is credited with catching  
several suspected insurgents in the Kabul area. Military units  
throughout the country routinely tap into the database.

While the U.S. has not forced the system on NATO, the Pentagon  
publication The Guardian noted American commanders were eager to see  
the technology put to use.

"An informal expectation exists within some U.S. ranks that NATO and  
ISAF should adopt U.S. policies and processes based on the U.S.  
experience," said the winter 20078 edition.

"NATO and ISAF welcome the U.S. experience with biometric systems."

An expanded screening program that included journalists was ordered  
late last winter.

Copyright © 2009 The Canadian Press. All rights reserved.