[R-G] [BillTottenWeblog] Change You Won't Believe

[Bill Totten]

Clusterfuck Nation

by Jim Kunstler

Comment on current events by the author of
The Long Emergency (Atlantic Monthly Press, 2005)

www.kunstler.com (December 15 2008)


The peak oil story has not been nullified by the scramble to unload
every asset for cash - including whomping gobs of oil contracts - during
this desperate season of bank liquidation. The main implication of the
peak oil story is that we won't be able to generate the kind of economic
growth that defined our way of life for decades because the primary
energy resources needed for it will be contracting.

Just as global oil production peaked, our economy evolved into a morbid
hypertrophy, and the chief manifestation of it was the suburban
sprawl-building fiesta that has now climaxed in the real estate bust. By
the early 21st century, when so much American manufacturing had been
swapped out to Asia, there was no business left except sprawl-building -
a manifold tragedy which wrecked the banks that financed it, and left
the ordinary people mortgaged to it with ruinous liabilities.

That economy is now in its death throes. The "normality" it represents
to so many Americans is gone and can't be brought back, no matter how
wistfully we watch it recede. Even so, it was obviously not good for the
country. The terrain of North America has been left scarred by unlovable
objects and baleful futureless vistas that, from now on, will shed
whatever pecuniary value they once had. It represents the physical
counterpart to the financial mess that has been left to the young
generations to clean up - and the job will take a very long time.

We have to, so to speak, get to place mentally where we can face the
kinds of change that are now necessary and unavoidable. We're not there
yet. It's not clear whether the elected new national leadership knows
just how severe the required changes will really be. Surely the public
would be shocked to grasp what's in store. Probably the worst thing we
can do now would be to mount a campaign to stay where we are, lost in
raptures of happy motoring and blue-light-special shopping.

The economy we're evolving into will be un-global, necessarily local and
regional, and austere. It won't support even our current population.
This being the case, the political fallout is also liable to be severe.
For one thing, we'll have to put aside our sentimental fantasies about
immigration. This is almost impossible to imagine, since that narrative
is especially potent among the Democratic Party members who are coming
in to run things. A tough immigration policy is exactly the kind of
difficult change we have to face. This is no longer the 19th century.
The narrative has to change.

The new narrative has to be about a managed contraction - and by
"managed" I mean a way that does not produce civil violence, starvation,
and public health disasters. One of the telltale signs to look for will
be whether the Obama administration bandies around the word "growth". If
you hear them use it, it will indicate that they don't understand the
kind of change we face.

It is hugely ironic that the US automobile industry is collapsing at
this very moment, and the ongoing debate about whether to "rescue" it or
not is an obvious kabuki theater exercise because this industry is
hopeless. It is headed into bankruptcy with one hundred percent
certainty. The only thing in question is whether the news of its death
will spoil the Christmas of those who draw a paycheck from it, or those
whose hopes for an easy retirement are vested in it. But American
political-economy being very Santa Claus oriented for recent
generations, the gesture will be made. A single leaky little lifeboat
will be lowered and the chiefs of the Big Three will be invited to go
for a brief little row, and then they will sink, glug, glug, glug, while
the rusty old Titanic of the car industry slides diagonally into the
deep behind them, against a sickening greenish-orange sunset backdrop of
the morbid economy.

A key concept of the economy to come is that size matters - everything
organized at the giant scale will suffer dysfunction and failure. Giant
companies, giant governments, giant institutions will all get into
trouble. This, unfortunately, doesn't bode so well for the Obama team
and it is salient reason why they must not mount a campaign to keep
things the way they are and support enterprises that have to be let go,
including many of the government's own operations. The best thing Mr
Obama can do is act as a wise counselor companion-in-chief to a people
who now have to leave a lot behind in order to move forward into a
plausible future. He seems well-suited to this task in sensibility and
intelligence. The task will surely include a degree of pretense that he
is holding some familiar things together and propping up some
touchstones of the comfortable life. But the truth is we are all going
to the same unfamiliar new territory.

The economy we're moving into will have to be one of real work,
producing real things of value, at a scale consistent with energy
resource reality. I'm convinced that farming will come much closer to
the center of economic life, as the death of petro-agribusiness makes
food production a matter of life and death in America - as opposed to
the disaster of metabolic entertainment it is now. Reorganizing the
landscape itself for this finer-scaled new type of farming is a task
fraught with political peril (land ownership questions being
historically one of the main reasons that societies fall into
revolution). The public is completely unprepared for this kind of
change. We still think that "the path to success" is based on getting a
college degree certifying people for a lifetime of sitting in an office
cubicle. This is so far from the approaching reality that it will be
eventually viewed as a sick joke - like those old 1912 lithographs of
mega-cities with Zeppelins plying the air between Everest-size skyscrapers.

The crucial element in the transformation underway will be emotion. The
American experience for a few generations has produced an adult
population with very childish instincts, increasingly worse each decade.
For instance, the desperate power fantasies among the younger tattooed
lumpenproles - those with next-to-zero real economic power - suggest a
certain unappetizing playing-out of resource competition when the supply
of Cheez Doodles and Pepsi starts to dwindle. But even the heretofore
gainfully employed middle classes are pretty lost in fantasies at least
of comfort an convenience. For years now, I have wondered how their
sense of grievance and resentment will be expressed when the supermarket
shelves run bare and the cardboard signs get taped over the local gas
pump and the cable TV gets cut off for non-payment. You wonder, to put
it bluntly, how far gone we really are.

_____

My new novel of the post-oil future, World Made By Hand, is available at
all booksellers.

http://jameshowardkunstler.typepad.com/clusterfuck_nation/2008/12/change-you-wont-believe.html


TO POST A COMMENT, OR TO READ COMMENTS POSTED BY OTHERS, please click
on the word "comment" highlighted at the end of the version of this
essay posted at http://billtotten.blogspot.com/