[R-G] Noted Arab Citizens Call on Israel to Shed Jewish Identity
critical.montages at gmail.com
Fri Feb 9 07:13:00 MST 2007
February 8, 2007
Noted Arab Citizens Call on Israel to Shed Jewish Identity
By ISABEL KERSHNER
JERUSALEM, Feb. 7 — A group of prominent Israeli Arabs has called on
Israel to stop defining itself as a Jewish state and become a
"consensual democracy for both Arabs and Jews," prompting
consternation and debate across the country.
Their contention is part of "The Future Vision of the Palestinian
Arabs in Israel," a report published in December under the auspices of
the Committee of Arab Mayors in Israel, which represents the country's
1.3 million Arab citizens, about a fifth of the population. Some 40
well-known academics and activists took part.
They call on the state to recognize Israeli Arab citizens as an
indigenous group with collective rights, saying Israel inherently
discriminates against non-Jewish citizens in its symbols of state,
some core laws, and budget and land allocations.
The authors propose a form of government, "consensual democracy," akin
to the Belgian model for Flemish- and French-speakers, involving
proportional representation and power-sharing in a central government
and autonomy for the Arab community in areas like education, culture
and religious affairs.
The document does not deal with the question of a Palestinian state in
the West Bank and Gaza Strip, where an additional three million
Palestinians live under Israeli occupation without Israeli
citizenship. The aim of the declaration is to reshape the future of
The reaction of Jewish Israelis has ranged from some understanding to
a more widespread response, indignation. Even among the center-left,
where concern for civil rights is common, some have condemned the
document as disturbing and harmful. On the right, Israeli Arabs have
been accused of constituting a "fifth column," a demographic and
strategic threat to the survival of the state.
Rassem Khamaisi, one of the Future Vision participants and an urban
planner, said: "The document reflects the Arab public's feelings of
discrimination. We should be looking for ways of partnership."
Many Israeli Arabs say they are second-class citizens who do not get
the same services and considerations as Jews and face discrimination
in employment, education and state institutions.
Last month, a Muslim Arab legislator from the Labor Party, Ghaleb
Majadele, was named a government minister, the first in Israel's
history. That development has been criticized as unhelpful by other
Israeli Arab politicians, who mostly boycott the mainstream Zionist
parties, running for Parliament on separate Arab lists and sitting in
In an interview, Mr. Majadele distanced himself from the new document,
saying that pragmatic political action would help the Arab sector more
than any ideological program. "The fact is that Israel is a Jewish
state, a state with a Jewish majority," he said. "Can we change that
reality with words?"
Yet Mr. Majadele said that he, too, felt uncomfortable with national
symbols like the flag, with a Star of David, and the anthem, which
speaks of the "Jewish soul" yearning for Zion.
"These were made and meant for the Jews, and did not take the Arab
minority into account," he said. "If Israel wants to integrate us
fully, then we need an anthem and flag that can do that. We and the
state must think deeply if we want to take a step in that direction.
But it must be by agreement, with the involvement of both sides."
Many of the Future Vision participants are affiliated with elite
Israeli academic institutions. For example, Asad Ghanem, one of the
document's principal authors, is head of the Government and Political
Theory Department at Haifa University's School of Political Science.
As such, both Jewish conservatives and liberals have been taken aback
by some propositions in the document. Many are angered by its
description of Israel as the outcome of a "settlement process
initiated by the Zionist Jewish elite" in the West and realized by
"colonial countries" in the wake of the Holocaust.
Jewish critics argue that the Future Vision report negates Israel's
legitimacy and raison d'être as the realization of Jewish
self-determination; further, they say it undermines the idea of a
two-state solution to the Israel-Palestinian conflict, since that
implies the establishment of a Palestinian state alongside a Jewish
In January, the senior fellows and board of the Israel Democracy
Institute, a generally liberal independent research group that has
worked on projects with some of the same Arab intellectuals, wrote a
response expressing "severe anguish" over the document's contents.
Prof. Shimon Shamir, a former Israeli ambassador to Jordan and Egypt,
published a letter in Al Sinara, an Arabic weekly in Israel, stating
that even among Jews who are generally sympathetic to Arab concerns,
the Future Vision document "evokes a sense of threat."
The document has exposed some raw nerves. Israel's Declaration of
Independence promises full equality in social and political rights to
all inhabitants, irrespective of religion, race or sex, and Israel's
Arab citizens participate in the country's democratic process.
Over the decades, however, Jewish-Arab relations in Israel have been
marked by mutual suspicion and resentment. From 1948 until 1966 Arabs
here lived under military rule. A 2003 government report acknowledged
discrimination by state institutions, and a recent report on poverty
published last year by Israel's National Insurance Institute indicated
that 53 percent of the impoverished families in Israel are Arabs.
And it is clear that the vast majority of Israel's Jews consider the
very essence of their state to be its Jewish identity.
Traditionally, Arab parties in the Parliament have focused on peace
and equality, but the Arab public has become frustrated with the lack
of results, leading to a lower voter turnout. Most Arab Israeli
politicians have rejected the Future Vision document as unrealistic,
exposing divisions within the Arab community.
Arab parties hold 10 seats in the 120-seat Parliament and are
sometimes accused by the Jewish establishment of provocations. During
last summer's Lebanon war, some Arab legislators were perceived as
sympathizing with Hezbollah.
Now there are signs of growing assertiveness and extremism on both
sides. Avigdor Lieberman, head of the hard-line Yisrael Beiteinu
Party, which has 11 seats in the Parliament, wants to reduce the
number of Arab Muslim citizens in Israel by eventually transferring
some populous Arab towns and their inhabitants to a future Palestinian
A few Jewish Israeli liberals have welcomed the Future Vision
document. Shalom (Shuli) Dichter, co-director of Sikkuy, a Jewish-Arab
organization that monitors civic equality in Israel, has hailed the
effort as opening a serious dialogue about the terms for genuine
Jewish-Arab co-existence though he, too, took issue with the
historical narrative adopted by the authors.
In January, 30,000 copies of the document were distributed to Arab
homes with weekend newspapers.
According to a poll of Arab Israelis by the Yafa Institute,
commissioned by the Konrad Adenauer Program for Jewish-Arab
Cooperation, only 14 percent of respondents said they thought Israel
should remain a Jewish and democratic state in its current format; 25
percent wanted a Jewish and democratic state that guarantees full
equality to its Arab citizens. But some 57 percent said they wanted a
change in the character and definition of the state, whether to become
a "state for all its citizens," a binational state, or a consensual
More information about the Rad-Green