[Marxism] Betancourt's halo [SIC] under spotlight
Jscotlive at aol.com
Jscotlive at aol.com
Sun Mar 1 01:36:25 MST 2009
Ruthless:
But the two are not the same. One can be vocal in critique of Hamas,
AND criticize Israeli oppression of Palestinians. In fact, that is the
principled position to take here.
Reply:
Oh yes it is! Hamas are the elected govt of the Palestinian people. By
joining in the ongoing attempt of the Israeli government and their allies in the
US, EU, and Egyptian govts in trying to use the election of Hamas as an excuse
to punish the Palestinians for daring to exercise their democratic right, you
give succour to the Zionist project to demonise and dehumanise any
Palestinian who would dare resist the occupation of their land.
This bullshit of the middle ground is an excuse for hand wringing as the
bombs and the missiles fall. There can be no middle ground between the oppressed
and oppressor. In such a context the middle ground is where paternalism
lies.
Ruthless:
By the same arguments, Marxists would be reduced to supporting Obama
because, after all, Obama is attacked by the right. Surely one sees
the absurdity of this line of mislogical reasoning.
Reply:
The only absurdity here is your continued attempts to equate moralism with
Marxism.
More information about the Marxism
mailing list