[Marxism] [PEN-L] Kerala model questioned

[Gopal Kappiarath]

The problems are more severe. The deep linguistic affinity ( among  
Keralites) sustains a high degree of cultural conformism
that prevents too many expressions of  dissent.

Religious hierarchies are still the norm. The church,  the muslim  
clergy and  the hindu priests still retain a high degree of
authority (cultural respect) that legitimates a sectarian worldview   
and an habitus of communal affiliation.

The average infant ( male ( and to a lesser extent female)  born in  
Kerala surely does have very good  life survival chances accorded
to by  the enhanced health/educational facilities.

But, living in Kerala means living in a particular culture, and those  
that  can  adapt/conform does well. To others, it can be/ and it is
oppressive.

Arundhati Roy  has made remarks about this.  As an independent/ 
critical thinking woman,  the dominant culture would  have been ( to  
say the least),
highly stifling for her.

"Communism" in  Kerala  has made many compromises, but none more  
dangerous and parochial than its tolerance of established religion.

Gopal




On Sep 7, 2007, at 7:01 PM, Louis Proyect wrote:

> NY Times, September 7, 2007
> Border Crossings
> Jobs Abroad Support ‘Model’ State in India
> By JASON DePARLE
>
> TRIVANDRUM, India — This verdant swath of southern Indian coastline  
> is a famously good place to be poor. People in the state of Kerala  
> live nearly as long as Americans do, on a sliver of the income.  
> They read at nearly the same rates.
>
> With leftist governments here in the state capital spending heavily  
> on health and schools, a generation of scholars has celebrated the  
> “Kerala model” as a humane alternative to market-driven  
> development, a vision of social equality in an unequal capitalist  
> world. But the Kerala model is under attack, one outbound worker at  
> a time.
>
> Plagued by chronic unemployment, more Keralites than ever work  
> abroad, often at sun-scorched jobs in the Persian Gulf that pay  
> about $1 an hour and keep them from their families for years. The  
> cash flowing home now helps support nearly one Kerala resident in  
> three. That has some local scholars rewriting the Kerala story: far  
> from escaping capitalism, they say, this celebrated corner of the  
> developing world is painfully dependent on it.
>
> “Remittances from global capitalism are carrying the whole Kerala  
> economy,” said S. Irudaya Rajan, a demographer at the Center for  
> Development Studies, a local research group. “There would have been  
> starvation deaths in Kerala if there had been no migration. The  
> Kerala model is good to read about but not practically applicable  
> to any part of the world, including Kerala.”
>
> Local lessons would matter less if this were a section of Mexico or  
> Manila — places known for the hardships that make migrants flee.  
> But Kerala’s standing as the other way — the benevolent path to  
> development, a retort to globalization — makes the travails of its  
> 1.8 million globalizing migrants especially resonant. The debate  
> about Kerala is a debate about future strategies across the  
> impoverished world.
>
> Laly Mohan’s life offers the kind of case study common here. Having  
> risen from a poor family to finish two years of college, her  
> husband, Ramakrishnan, 39, saw few job prospects and left for the  
> gulf 15 years ago. As a driver in Qatar, he now earns $375 a month,  
> about five times the local wage, and sees his family once a year,  
> on a three-week visit.
>
> Mr. Mohan’s earnings have brought the family the accouterments of  
> middle-class life: a renovated kitchen, a new motorscooter and a  
> parochial school education for two daughters, Blessy, 10, and Elsa,  
> 6. But despite her husband’s daily calls, Ms. Mohan said, “I feel  
> very alone,” and the girls plead for their father’s return. “They  
> want Papa and they also want money,” she said. “They cannot have  
> both.”
>
> “So many educated people are here, but we have no jobs,” Ms. Mohan  
> added. “That is a big problem, a really big problem.”
>
> To its admirers, the state’s struggles are those endemic to the  
> developing world, while its achievements are unique. It is poor,  
> even by India’s standards, with an annual per capita income of  
> $675, compared with $730 nationwide. (The figure in the United  
> States is about $25,000.)
>
> But Kerala’s life expectancy is nearly 74 years — 11 years longer  
> than the Indian average and approaching the American average of 77  
> years. Its literacy rate, 91 percent, compares to an Indian average  
> of 65 percent, and an American rate the United Nations estimates at  
> 99 percent.
>
> Those enviable outcomes, its supporters stress, are a result of  
> policy choices: Kerala spends 36 percent more on education than the  
> average Indian state and 46 percent more on health.
>
> “The fact that quality of life can be improved through government  
> intervention, even in societies that are very poor — I think that’s  
> important,” said Prabhat Patnaik, the vice chairman of the state  
> planning board. Kerala’s experience, he said, shows “the quality of  
> life is not just related to the growth rate” of the economy.
>
> “Put it in the context of any other part of the developing world  
> and its achievements still stand out as remarkable,” said Richard  
> Franke, an anthropologist at Montclair State University in New  
> Jersey. “Children don’t die in the first year of life, boys and  
> girls have approximately equal life chances, they get educated, and  
> they live long lives.”
>
> He added, “The Kerala model stands as a great achievement, with or  
> without migration.”
>
> Kerala’s culture of human investment is at least two centuries  
> years old and owes early debts to the missionaries and maharajahs  
> who emphasized schools. By the early 20th century, literate  
> Keralites were already migrating internally, to work as clerks in  
> Delhi and Bombay, and sending money home.
>
> Kerala was equally well known as a font of leftist politics. The  
> Communist Party came to power in 1957, a year after statehood, and  
> has ruled on and off since. The state transferred land from the  
> rich to the poor, set a minimum wage and invested heavily in  
> clinics and schools.
>
> Though Kerala’s tax rates have been comparable to other Indian  
> states’, its collection rates have been higher, and it has spent  
> more on education and health.
>
> It also gained a reputation as a place hostile to business, with  
> heavy regulation, militant unions and frequent strikes. There are  
> fishing jobs but little industry and weak agriculture. Government  
> is the largest employer; many people run tenuous businesses like  
> tea shops or tiny stores.
>
> Talk of the Kerala model began after a 1975 United Nations report  
> praised the state’s “impressive advances in the spheres of health  
> and education.” Starved for success stories from the developing  
> world, experts noticed.
>
> Amartya Sen, a future Nobel laureate in economics, wrote widely on  
> Kerala, arguing (in a book with Jean Dreze) that its “outstanding  
> social achievements” were of “far-reaching significance” in other  
> countries. In a book on three places that inspire global hope, Bill  
> McKibben, an American, wrote that “Kerala demonstrates that a low- 
> level economy can create a decent life” and shows that “sharing  
> works.”
>
> Yet even as Kerala gained fame, large numbers of its workers were  
> leaving. The Persian Gulf needed labor, and Keralites were used to  
> traveling for jobs. The number of overseas workers doubled in the  
> 1980s, and then tripled in the 1990s. In a state of 32 million  
> where unemployment approaches 20 percent, one Keralite worker in  
> six now works overseas. The largest number work at taxing  
> construction jobs, outdoors in the Arabian sun, though high  
> literacy allows some Keralites to land office work.
>
> Without migrant earnings, critics say, the state’s luster could not  
> be sustained. The $5 billion that Keralite migrants send home  
> augment the state’s economic output by nearly 25 percent. Migrants’  
> families are three times as likely as those of nonmigrants to live  
> in superior housing, and about twice as likely to have telephones,  
> refrigerators and cars. Men seeking wives place newspaper ads,  
> describing themselves as “handsome, teetotaler, foreign-employed”  
> or “God-fearing and working in Dubai.”
>
> “The gulf is the biggest factor in sustaining a higher quality of  
> life,” said B. A. Prakesh, an economist at the University of Kerala.
>
> At its best, migration produces stories like that of Benjamin  
> Fernandez, 55, who moved to the United Arab Emirates 30 years ago  
> as a secretary and now owns a construction firm there. He built a  
> big house in India with a teak spiral staircase and educated his  
> daughters in private schools. One is studying to be a doctor, and  
> the other is applying to business school. “The U.A.E. built a life  
> for us,” he said.
>
> Yet the suicide rate in Kerala is four times the national average,  
> and there are also families like that of Shirley Justus, 45, who  
> struggled to raise three daughters by herself while her husband  
> drove trucks in Muscat and Dubai. Her oldest, Suji, graduated from  
> high school last year and made two study plans, one aimed at  
> England and the other at Mumbai, formerly known as Bombay. Ms.  
> Justus, afraid to be responsible for letting her go, vetoed both  
> ideas. Her daughter obeyed with little complaint and then hanged  
> herself.
>
> “If my husband was here, she wouldn’t have done this,” said Ms.  
> Justus, who has made her living room a shrine to her daughter and  
> her life a search for answers. “He would have solved the problem.”
>
> With nearly a quarter of the money migrants send home being spent  
> on education, some Keralites experience a painful cycle: migration  
> buys education, which leads to more migration. Educated Keralites,  
> more choosy about jobs, are more likely to be unemployed.
>
> In the family of James John Pereira, literacy and migration have  
> been intertwined for nearly 100 years, since his father left to  
> work as a valet on a Sri Lankan plantation. His earnings put Mr.  
> Pereira through private school, and Mr. Pereira’s 49 years abroad  
> as a clerk did the same for his five children, all of whom earned  
> master’s degrees.
>
> But three are now working abroad themselves, as is the husband of a  
> fourth, Jacqueline, who is raising a 10-year-old daughter by  
> herself. “The literacy rate here is great,” she said, “and  
> unemployment is much greater.”
>
> Kerala’s homegrown critics say such stories underscore the problems  
> of a strategy that severs human development and economic growth.  
> “Keralites are developing the gulf economy,” Professor Rajan, the  
> demographer, said. “They are not developing our economy.”
>
> Professor Franke, the Kerala admirer, said the economic forces that  
> lead people to migrate were beyond the state’s control. “But what’s  
> unique about Kerala is that the benefits are likely to be shared in  
> a more fair and just way,” he said.
>
> “I wouldn’t say it discredits the model,” Mr. Franke said of  
> Kerala’s migration. “It shows that it has weaknesses.”