[Marxism] Best bios of Marx and Lenin?

Rakesh Bhandari bhandari at berkeley.edu
Sun Oct 22 09:27:02 MDT 2006



Does anyone know of a 1921 biography of KM by a German sociologist, 
Ferdinand Toennies (my great grandfather)? I'd once seen an english 
translation of this work, but can't recall its quality and biases.

Hi Patrick,

Your great grandfather certainly knew Marx's economic writings very 
well. He faults Marx's labor theory of value for ruling out the 
entrepreneurial contribution to surplus value formation.

I remember his historical analysis of the emergence of capitalism as 
stimulating; he rethinks the importance of merchant capital.

I haven't unpacked my books, so I can't consult my copy.

To the excellent recommendations of Marx biographies, I would add Max 
Beer's, and I would recommend Marx Wartofsky's critique of 
Kolakowski's study.

Rakesh


More information about the Marxism mailing list