M-TH: CHRIS B AHISTORICAL STOOGE OF FASCIST Q & A METHOD 1

[Hugh Rodwell]

What a relief that Thaxis doesn't have a three-post limit!

Chris B, burning with eagerness to learn, wrote:

>I was disappointed that Hugh did not respond to my previous
>challenge to clarify whether his support for Lenin's
>arguments in Letters on Tactics does or does not imply
>support for a *strategy* involving stages of a revolution.
>
>I am therefore repeating my post below and look forward
>to his reply.

etc


Patience, Chris, old son...

Haven't you read what the herd thinks about the evils of ASKING QUESTIONS
AND DEMANDING ANSWERS? So no questions until they ripen of their own accord
once the WELTGEIST decides they've been mushed into a soft enough pulp  by
the ruthless critique of what is. It'd be like apples falling on your head
(anyone see Young Einstein?), only you'd get a head full of squish instead
of a flash of inspiration.

Marx obviously never asked any questions until the WELTGEIST's critique of
bourgeois right and economics etc was done and lay before him in the first
edition of Capital. It's a miracle the way the critique can do its work
without asking questions and demanding answers, but there you are. Ours not
to reason why, ours but to remain silent and be lectured at.

Cheers,

Hugh




     --- from list marxism-thaxis at lists.village.virginia.edu ---