[A-List] James Petras on Beslan - fire away

[Waistline2 at aol.com]

>> Nevertheless . . . Beslan  . . . the hostage taking and murder of children 
is avoided by the "left ideological frontmen" of the imperial bourgeoisie and 
presented as a colonial question and anti-colonial actions and this is not 
the case. <<

Comment

Lou disagrees and says the Irish bombing of targets in England is that same 
as the terror that is Beslan. 

Lou disagrees with what I wrote and says the Palestinian assaults against the 
Israeli State and oppressor people is that same as that which is Beslan. 

I got a world map and several maps and can look and see where Ireland is on 
the map and England. I can look and see where Israel is and the relationship of 
her imperial expansion at the expense of the Palestinian peoples. 

See . . . something's have nothing to do with some profound sense of Leninism 
or mystical class struggle. 

Lou P is the white chauvinists he has always been and this is so obvious when 
anyone reads what he writes about our own - American . . . Working class. 

Lets me understand what was written. Lou says that the struggle of the Irish 
against English oppression and the struggle of the Palestinian against the 
Israeli State is the same struggle that is in the events of Beslan. 

Let me quote what he wrote so there is no misunderstanding. 

>>The Palestinians use terror as well. We should not condemn the struggle 
against Zionism because suicide bombers kill innocent civilians. What we 
need to resolve is not whether terror is counter-productive, but whether 
  the Chechen cause is just.

he Czars colonized the Caucuses in exactly the same 
manner as England colonized Ireland.<<

Lou is a white chauvinist rat and has always been one . . . and he insists on 
me taking him to the mat again. See . . . Lou . . . you can't play the Jew 
game with me . . . like you did with Henry . . . and you cannot claim any class 
instinct of history in the American Union other than that of a big mouth rat. 

Lets be clear. I am claiming juice and a verifiable history within the most 
organized sector of the workers in American and the most poverty stricken and a 
verifiable specific history on raising the Palestinian Question in the 
American history since 1968. 

The real issue is Belsan and why you pretend this is an aspect of the 
emancipation of the workers in North Ossetia.

You need to shut up. Then . . . again I will shut up your anti-Sovietism and 
anti-Russian Chauvinism. 

Try the Jew card on me Lou. 

Melvin P.